| Platinum | Tony Pepperoni |
| Gold | Tasty Pizza |
| Silver | Bear Roots Brewing Co. |
| Bronze | Filippi's Pizza Grotto |
| Top Pick | Best Pizza & Brew Escondido |
| Top Pick | Meadows Deli Market |
| Top Pick | Rocco's Pizza & Deli |
| Top Pick | Rock On Pizza East Coast Style Thin Crust |
| Top Pick | Tikka Pizza Kitchen |